I'm also looking to get a new mitt. I like Akadema, but I don't remember how the mitt sizing works. I mean I know what is offered, 32.5, 34, etc. but I'm not sure what would be appropriate for my hand.

I can say that I have a medium sized hand, thicker more than longer hand and fingers.

I'm glad some one asked this, Dad is looking to get a catchers mitt to catch for Son. I have no idea how the sizing works sometimes they say 14 or 13.5. Will some one please explain this.

It measures the circumference. Larger the hand, larger the glove. I don't have big hands but used a 34 for a while and wasn't a problem. Now I switched to a 33.5.

Ya I have a 34 inch and like it a lot. It gives you that extra bit to hang onto those foul tips. If you have a medium sized hand like me Id say look for a 34 inch one. But its your call in the end, not mine. Ive never had any experience with Akadema so I cant help you there. Sorry thats all I got.

The Rawlings Pro-Preferred are typically one of the smallest mitts on the market. All-Star usually has the biggest.
I've worn all types and sizes, and personally prefer a small to medium size mitt.
The faster the pitching, the less time a catcher has to react to the pitch. So, if you seem to be a little behind the pitch, a bigger mitt might be best for you. If you're catching the ball just fine, a smaller, lighter mitt may be more comfortable.

As a rule of thumb, I've always tried to use the smallest mitt that I was comfortable and effective with, whether it be a 32 or a 33 inch...